Objects and documents belonging to long-term residents of a now-shuttered
psychiatric hospital form a museum exhibit that gives visitors insight into
the patients' lives.
Old family photographs. A few dishes wrapped in newspaper. A baby's
nightgown. Letters from home.
The bits and pieces of lives of residents of New York's Willard State
Hospital, packed into suitcases and hidden away in the hospital attic, were
brought to light again in an exhibition on view in September at the offices of
the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration in Rockville,
Md. The exhibit, “The Lives They Left Behind,” is scheduled to
travel around the United States for at least another two years.
“You don't often see the perspective of people who were
institutionalized then,” said exhibition co-curator Darby Penney,
M.L.S., president of the Community Consortium, an advocacy group for people
with psychiatric disablilities.
The exhibit's origins date back to 1995, when Willard Psychiatric Center
(as it was finally known) in New York's Finger Lakes region closed down. Staff
members found 400 suitcases tucked away on wooden racks and sent them to the
New York State Museum in Albany.
Beginning in 1999, Penney, then director of recipient affairs at the New
York State Office of Mental Health, and Peter Stastny, M.D., an associate
clinical professor of psychiatry at Albert Einstein College of Medicine,
studied a selected group of the suitcases.
Using hospital records, they examined the patients' medical records and
correspondence, combed through the snapshots, and tracked down patients'
relatives and former hospital employees. They also read transcriptions of
intake interviews, a chance to hear an echo of each person's voice.
Photographer Lisa Rinzler documented the artifacts, gravesites, and former
homes of the patients. The traveling exhibit is a briefer version of one
displayed at the New York State Museum in 2004.
The patients brought these trunks with them on arrival, but they were not
permitted to keep them in their rooms. Exactly why they couldn't keep their
trunks or the personal treasures they contained in their rooms is not known,
said Penney. Thus, the items in the exhibit reflect the patients' lives prior
to their hospitalization.
Once placed in storage, the suitcases were forgotten over the decades that
their owners stayed at Willard.
Ethel was a seamstress who spent 43 years in Willard, working part time in
the laundry and making quilts and baby booties in her spare time. Herman's
seizures led doctors to send him to Willard, and 35 years inside probably made
him depressed and uncommunicative before he died in 1965. Dymytro was a Nazi
slave-camp survivor from the Ukraine who underwent 20 electroconvulsive
therapy sessions and finished one painting every day for years. Margaret was a
Scottish immigrant, a nurse who served in World War I. A history of
tuberculosis, compounded by emotional problems, led to her commitment in 1941.
She received no psychotherapy, only Thorazine.
Many of these people would be unlikely to need long-term inpatient
treatment today, giving added poignancy to the exhibit.
“We tried to put the focus on the psychiatric history of that
time,” said Penney. She and Stastny are collaborating on a related book
that will be published next fall.
“The Lives They Left Behind: Suitcases From a State Hospital
Attic” was designed and produced by the Exhibition Alliance.
More images and information about the exhibit are posted at<www.suitcaseexhibit.org>.▪
1 Suitcases filled with the belongings of earlier lives of patients at
Willard State Hospital in upstate New York form the basis of the
exhibit.
3 Sophia's early death during a miscarriage was said to set her husband,
Dymytro, on the path to mental illness. As part of his rehabilitation, he
began painting and turned out one picture a day—many of village scenes
of his native Ukraine 5 —for years.
6 These books and photographs belonged to Madeline. She went from the
unemployment lines in the Depression to voluntary commitment to long-term
involuntary commitment at Willard. Given antipsychotic drugs in the 1950s
despite her objections, she developed tardive dyskinesia and spent the rest of
her life in institutions.
Margaret was an immigrant nurse from Scotland. She was sent to Willard
in 1941, where she remained for 32 years. The teacup 2, medical charts 4, and
small photos 7 belonged to her.