The agency first developed the concept of "pediatric exclusivity"—voluntary submission by drug manufacturers of minimal data on safety of their medications in children in exchange for extended patent protection. When the exclusivity program proved not to be very productive, the agency formulated the "pediatric rule," requiring submission of the data included with any new drug application. In October 2000, however, the pediatric rule was struck down in federal court, when justices agreed with industry claims that the FDA lacked the statutory authority to require the research (Psychiatric News, September 19, 2003).