Atest of self-managed cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) conducted live
over the Internet with therapists may expand treatment options for military
personnel with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), if results from a small,
proof-of-concept trial are any indication.
"Most people don't get the help they need following mass trauma or
war," said Brett Litz, Ph.D., lead author on the study, which appeared
in the November American Journal of Psychiatry, in an interview."
They need constant face-to-face care with experts, and that's not a
Most studies on PTSD treatments have been carried out among veterans or
civilian victims of trauma. To his knowledge, this was only the second
randomized, controlled study of a mental health intervention held within the
Department of Defense, he said.
The trial was not "computer therapy," Litz emphasized.
Computers and the Internet were simply the vehicles for delivering the
service. The real work involved interactions between patients and clinicians,
he said. "At the 'back end,' therapists could follow each patient,
monitor any regression, and produce daily ratings."
Litz, of Boston Veterans Affairs Healthcare, Boston University School of
Medicine, and National Center for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, collaborated
with Charles Engel, M.D., M.P.H., of the Uniformed Services University of the
Health Sciences and Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Bethesda, Md.; Richard
Bryant, Ph.D., of the University of New South Wales in Sydney, Australia; and
Anthony Papa, Ph.D., of Boston University School of Medicine.
The intervention was geared toward the needs of military service members,
who are often short of spare time and are concerned about the stigma attached
to issues of mental illness, said Litz.
Their patients were Department of Defense service members who developed
PTSD following the September 11 attack on the Pentagon or after combat in Iraq
or Afghanistan. The researchers screened 141 volunteers and recruited 45 for
random assignment, of whom 33 completed the treatment protocol. Subjects were
initially assessed in face-to-face sessions with therapists using the PTSD
Symptom Scale-Interview Version, the Beck Depression Inventory-II, and the
Beck Anxiety Inventory. They were evaluated again after eight weeks of
treatment (permitting up to 56 possible sessions), and at three and six months
They titled their program DESTRESS—DElivery of Self-TRaining and
Education for Stressful Situations—as a way of reducing stigma and
emphasizing self-care aspects.
In the CBT arm, patients learned coping skills through homework assignments
to handle the inevitable stressful situations they encountered in daily life,
After learning those stress-management strategies, they began graduated
exposure to the triggers, followed by seven online sessions during which they
wrote about their traumas. "The goal was to promote mastery and reduce
avoidance," said the researchers. They also had access by phone or
e-mail to their therapists, who included psychologists and a social
The second study arm consisted of a control group of 21 patients who
received supportive counseling and were asked to monitor nontrauma-related,
present-day concerns and write about those experiences. Both groups also had
Web access to educational materials about PTSD, stress, trauma, depression,
and strategies to manage anger or sleep problems.
The PTSD symptoms of patients improved in both study arms, although the CBT
intervention produced a sharper decline in severity. Out of the 33 patients
who completed the eight weeks of CBT treatment, 24 also were assessed at the
three-month follow-up, and 18 at the six-month follow-up.
At three months, there was no difference between those who did or did not
complete the protocol, but at six months, completers in the self-management
CBT arm had significantly fewer PTSD, depression, and anxiety symptoms.
The difference at six months between the two arms might be explained by the
better strategies absorbed by the CBT patients, said Litz.
"They learn to manage challenges," he said. "That ability
sinks in with sufficient successful experience, and it builds confidence in
The intervention also made good use of the therapists' time. They were able
to look after more patients than they would in a similar number of office
visits, said Litz. "The net time per case probably averaged about 15
minutes per week over the course of the eight weeks."
This study is just the beginning of research using this style of
intervention, said Litz. Members of the research team will continue to study
its utility in U.S. Marines newly returned from Iraq and also in primary care
settings at Fort Bragg, N.C., and at the Charleston (S.C.) Veterans Affairs
"A Randomized, Controlled Proof-of-Concept Trial of an
Internet-Based, Therapist-Assisted Self-Management Treatment for Posttraumatic
Stress Disorder" is posted at<http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/full/164/11/1676>.▪